Needles in a haystack: an intersectional analysis of the descriptive, constitutive and substantive representation of minoritised women
Using a data set of 1.1 million speeches drawn from UK House of Commons debates during 1997–2017 and a combination of automated and manual content analysis, this study addresses three interrelated questions. First, to what extent are minoritised women constitutively represented in parliamentary debates? Second, which MPs do so? Third, how do MPs’ race and gender affect how they represent minoritised women? I find that minoritised women are mentioned exceptionally rarely in parliamentary debates. Furthermore, descriptive representatives are not only substantially more likely to mention minoritised women than other MPs, but they also improve the quality of representation by doing so in relation to a wider range of issues. Yet, paradoxically, white men’s descriptive over-representation means that they account for the vast majority of mentions of minoritised women. More broadly, I foreground the distinction between constitutive and substantive representation, highlighting the importance of distinguishing between speaking about and on behalf of.
-
Allen, P. and Childs, S. (2019) The grit in the oyster? Women’s parliamentary organizations and the substantive representation of women, Political Studies, 67(3): 618–38. doi: 10.1177/0032321718793080
-
Bajpai, R. (2019) What do descriptive representatives describe? Minority representative claims and the limits of shape-shifting, Ethnicities, 19(5): 740–62. doi: 10.1177/1468796819847497
-
Bergtold, J.S., Yeager, E.A. and Featherstone, A.M. (2018) Inferences from logistic regression models in the presence of small samples, rare events, nonlinearity, and multicollinearity with observational data, Journal of Applied Statistics, 45(3): 528–46. doi: 10.1080/02664763.2017.1282441
-
Bilge, S. (2013) Intersectionality undone, Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race, 10(2): 405–24. doi: 10.1017/S1742058X13000283
-
Blumenau, J. (2021) House of commons parliamentary debates, 1979–2019, [Data Collection]. Colchester, Essex: UK Data Service. doi: 10.5255/UKDA-SN-854292.
-
Brown, N. (2014) Sisters in the Statehouse: Black Women and Legislative Decision Making, New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
-
Celis, K. (2009) Substantive representation of women (and improving it): what it is and should be about?, Comparative European Politics, 7(1): 95–113. doi: 10.1057/cep.2008.35
-
Celis, K. (2013) Representativity in times of diversity: the political representation of women, Women’s Studies International Forum, 41(3): 179–86.
-
Celis, K. and Mügge, L.M. (2018) Whose equality? Measuring group representation, Politics, 38(2): 197–213. doi: 10.1177/0263395716684527
-
Celis, K. and Childs, S. (2023) From women’s presence to feminist representation: second-generation design for women’s group representation, European Journal of Politics and Gender, XX(XX): 1–18, doi: 10.1332/251510821X16654996784749.
-
Celis, K., Childs, S., Kantola, J. and Krook, M.L. (2008) Rethinking women’s substantive representation, Representation, 44(2): 99–110. doi: 10.1080/00344890802079573
-
Celis, K., Erzeel, S., Mügge, L. and Damstra, A. (2014) Quotas and intersectionality: ethnicity and gender in candidate selection, International Political Science Review, 35(1): 41–54. doi: 10.1177/0192512113507733
-
Celis, K., Erzeel, S. and Mügge, L. (2015) Intersectional puzzles: understanding inclusion and equality in political recruitment, Politics & Gender, 11(4): 765.
-
Childs, S. (2004) New Labour’s Women MPs: Women Representing Women, London: Routledge.
-
Childs, S. and Krook, M.L. (2009) Analysing women’s substantive representation: from critical mass to critical actors, Government and Opposition, 44(2): 125–45. doi: 10.1111/j.1477-7053.2009.01279.x
-
Collins, P.H. (1990) Black feminist thought in the matrix of domination, in Black Feminist Thought: Knowledge, Consciousness, and the Politics of Empowerment, 138(1990): 221–38.
-
Collins, P.H. and Bilge, S. (2016) Intersectionality, Cambridge: John Wiley & Sons.
-
Combahee River Collective (1977) A black feminist statement, in G.T. Hull, P. Bell-Scott and B. Smith (eds) All the Women Are White, All the Blacks Are Men, But Some of Us Are Brave. Black Women’s Studies, New York: The Feminist Press at the City University of New York, pp 13–22.
-
Crenshaw, K. (1989) Demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex: a black feminist critique of antidiscrimination doctrine, feminist theory and antiracist politics, University of Chicago Legal Forum, 1: 139.
-
Crenshaw, K. (1991) Mapping the margins: intersectionality, identity politics, and violence against women of color, Stanford Law Review, 43(6): 1241–99. doi: 10.2307/1229039
-
Crowder-Meyer, M. (2021) How gender, race, ethnicity, and their intersections shape Americans’ issue priorities, Journal of Women, Politics & Policy, 1–15.
-
Durose, C., Combs, R., Eason, C., Gains, F. and Richardson, L. (2012) ‘Acceptable difference’: diversity, representation and pathways to UK politics, Parliamentary Affairs, 66(2): 246–67.
-
Erzeel, S. and Rashkova, E. (2023) The substantive representation of social groups: towards a new comparative research agenda, European Journal of Politics and Gender, XX(XX): 1–19, doi: 10.1332/251510821X16635712428686.
-
Fernandes, J.M., Debus, M. and Bäck, H. (2021) Unpacking the politics of legislative debates, European Journal of Political Research, 60(4): 1032–45.
-
Fox, J.E., Moroşanu, L. and Szilassy, E. (2012) The racialization of the new European migration to the UK, Sociology, 46(4): 680–95. doi: 10.1177/0038038511425558
-
Freidenvall, L. (2016) Intersectionality and candidate selection in Sweden, Politics, 36(4): 355–63. doi: 10.1177/0263395715621931
-
Hardy-Fanta, C., Lien, P.t., Pinderhughes, D.M. and Sierra, C.M. (2006) Gender, race, and descriptive representation in the United States: findings from the Gender and Multicultural Leadership Project, Journal of Women, Politics & Policy, 28(3–4): 7–41. doi: 10.1300/J501v28n03_02
-
Hawkesworth, M. (2003) Congressional enactments of Race-gender: toward a theory of Raced-gendered institutions, American Political Science Review, 97(4): 529–50. doi: 10.1017/S0003055403000868
-
Ho, P., Chen, K., Shao, A., Bao, L., Ai, A., Tarfa, A., Brossard, D., Brown, L. and Brauer, M. (2021) A mixed methods study of public perception of social distancing: integrating qualitative and computational analyses for text data, Journal of Mixed Methods Research, 15(3): 374–97. doi: 10.1177/15586898211020862
-
Höhmann, D. and Nugent, M. (2021) Male MPs, electoral vulnerability and the substantive representation of women’s interests, European Journal of Political Research, 61(3): 762–82.
-
hooks, b. (1981) Ain’t I a Woman: Black Women and Feminism, Boston, MA: South End Press.
-
Hughes, M. (2011) Intersectionality, quotas, and minority women’s political representation worldwide, American Political Science Review, 105(3): 604–20. doi: 10.1017/S0003055411000293
-
Hughes, M. (2013) The intersection of gender and minority status in national legislatures: the Minority Women Legislative Index, Legislative Studies Quarterly, 38(4): 489–516. doi: 10.1111/lsq.12025
-
Johnson, A., Tolley, E., Thomas, M. and Bodet, M.A. (2021) A new dataset on the demographics of Canadian federal election candidates, Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue Canadienne de Science Politique, 54(3): 717–25. doi: 10.1017/S0008423921000391
-
Joly, D. and Wadia, K. (2017) Muslim Women and Power, London: Springer.
-
Jordan-Zachery, J.S. (2007) Am I a black woman or a woman who is black? A few thoughts on the meaning of intersectionality, Politics & Gender, 3(2): 254–63.
-
Junn, J. and Brown, N. (2008) What revolution? Incorporating intersectionality in women and politics, in C. Wolbrecht, K. Beckwith and L. Baldez (eds) Political Women and American Democracy, New York: Cambridge University Press, pp 64–78.
-
Keen, R. (2015) Women in parliament and government, Standard Note SN01250, House of Commons Library.
-
King, D.K. (1988) Multiple jeopardy, multiple consciousness: the context of a black feminist ideology, Signs, 14(1): 42–72. doi: 10.1086/494491
-
Krook, M.L. and Nugent, M.K. (2016) Intersectional institutions: representing women and ethnic minorities in the British Labour Party, Party Politics, 22(5): 620–30
-
Mackay, F. (2008) ‘Thick’ conceptions of substantive representation: women, gender and political institutions, Representation, 44(2): 125–39. doi: 10.1080/00344890802079607
-
McCall, L. (2005) The complexity of intersectionality, Signs, 30(3): 1771–800. doi: 10.1086/426800
-
Milner, A. and Jumbe, S. (2020) Using the right words to address racial disparities in COVID-19, The Lancet Public Health, 5(8): e419–20. doi: 10.1016/S2468-2667(20)30162-6
-
Minta, M.D. and Brown, N.E. (2014) Intersecting interests: gender, race, and congressional attention to women’s issues, Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race, 11(2): 253–72. doi: 10.1017/S1742058X14000186
-
Mügge, L.M. (2016) Intersectionality, recruitment and selection: ethnic minority candidates in Dutch parties, Parliamentary Affairs, 69(3): 512–30.
-
Mügge, L.M., Montoya, C., Emejulu, A. and Weldon, S.L. (2018) Intersectionality and the politics of knowledge production, European Journal of Politics and Gender, 1(1–2): 17–36.
-
Mügge, L.M., van der Pas, D.J. and van de Wardt, M. (2019) Representing their own? Ethnic minority women in the Dutch Parliament, West European Politics, 42(4): 705–27.
-
Murray, R. (2016) The political representation of ethnic minority women in France, Parliamentary Affairs, 69(3): 586–602.
-
O’Brien, C. (2010) Hard times for who? Passing violence against women legislation in Nigeria, APSA 2010 Annual Meeting Paper, https://ssrn.com/abstract=1657334.
-
Proksch, S.O. and Slapin, J.B. (2012) Institutional foundations of legislative speech, American Journal of Political Science, 56(3): 520–37. doi: 10.1111/j.1540-5907.2011.00565.x
-
Reingold, B. and Swers, M. (2011) An endogenous approach to women’s interests: when interests are interesting in and of themselves, Politics & Gender, 7(3): 429–35.
-
Saward, M. (2006) Democracy and citizenship: expanding domains, in J.S. Dryzek, B. Honig and A. Phillips (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Political Theory, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
-
Schreier, M. (2012) Qualitative Content Analysis in Practice, London: Sage Publications.
-
Shaw, S. (2020) Women, Language and Politics, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
-
Smooth, W. (2006) Intersectionality in electoral politics: a mess worth making, Politics & Gender, 2(3): 400–14.
-
Smooth, W. (2011) Standing for women? Which women? The substantive representation of women’s interests and the research imperative of intersectionality, Politics & Gender, 7(3): 436–41.
-
Sobolewska, M., McKee, R. and Campbell, R. (2018) Explaining motivation to represent: how does descriptive representation lead to substantive representation of racial and ethnic minorities?, West European Politics, 41(6): 1237–61. doi: 10.1080/01402382.2018.1455408
-
Sojka, A. (2019) Liminal Europeanness: whiteness, East–West mobility, and European citizenship, in T. Kulawik and Z. Kravchenko (eds) Borderlands in European Gender Studies: Beyond the East–West Frontier, Abingdon: Routledge.
-
Squires, J. (2008) The constitutive representation of gender: extra‐parliamentary re‐presentations of gender relations, Representation, 44(2): 187–204. doi: 10.1080/00344890802080464
-
Uberoi, E. and Lees, R. (2020) Ethnic diversity in politics and public life, House of Commons Briefing Paper 01156.
-
Wood, J. and Cracknell, R. (2013) Ethnic Minorities in Politics, Government, and Public Life, London: House of Commons Library.
-
Yildirim, T.M. (2022) Rethinking women’s interests: an inductive and intersectional approach to defining women’s policy priorities, British Journal of Political Science, 52(3): 1240–57.
| May 2022 onwards | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 408 | 408 | 7 |
| Full Text Views | 580 | 580 | 164 |
| PDF Downloads | 347 | 347 | 134 |
We are a leading social science publisher
committed to making a difference.
Bristol University Press and
Policy Press
bristoluniversitypress.co.uk