Measuring the health impact of Universal Basic Income as an upstream intervention: holistic trial design that captures stress reduction is essential
Background:
In the context of the UK Government’s ‘prevention agenda’, Laura Webber and colleagues have called for a ‘health in all policies’ approach. Universal Basic Income (UBI) is a system of cash transfers to citizens. Recent research suggests it could significantly benefit population health, including via reducing stress. However, a Finnish trial of a policy with similarities to UBI has influenced debate. This was reported as a failure due to a policy objective of reducing unemployment, despite demonstrating significant benefits to well-being.
Aims and objectives:
In this piece, we seek to advance the debate about the cost-benefit of UBI by identifying knowledge gaps and proposing a means of designing effective trials.
Methods:
We review UBI trial design and findings in comparison with social gradient in health literature and biopsychosocial theory to identify knowledge gaps.
Findings:
We highlight a need to refocus UBI trials on improved health, including via reduced stress, to provide policy makers the means of producing accurate cost-benefit analysis. Previous trials have either not reflected likely UBI policy or failed to measure impacts that enable accurate analysis. We contend that interdisciplinary work is required to establish trials that observe factors known to drive the social health gradient. Finally, we argue that statistical modelling is needed to extrapolate shorter-term findings to long-term population-level outcomes.
Discussion and conclusions:
Resource allocation by Government and/or major funders is required to produce evidence that enables accurate analysis of UBI. Such trials would provide a platform for interdisciplinary work resulting in joined-up evidence and policy.
-
Akee, R., Simeonova, E., Copeland, W., Angold, A. and Costello, E.J. (2013) Young adult obesity and household income: effects of unconditional cash transfers, American Economic Journal, 5(2): 1–28.
-
Alston, P. (2018) Statement on Visit to the United Kingdom, by Professor Philip Alston, United Nations Special Rapporteur on Extreme Poverty and Human Rights, Geneva: Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights.
-
Brant, H., Wetherell, M.A., Lightman, S., Crown, A. and Vedhara, K. (2010) An exploration into physiological and self-report measures of stress in preregistration doctors at the beginning and end of a clinical rotation, Stress, 13(2): 155–162. doi: 10.3109/10253890903093778
-
Chida, Y. and Steptoe, A. (2009) Cortisol awakening response and psychosocial factors: a systematic review and meta-analysis, Biological Psychology, 80(3): 265–278. doi: 10.1016/j.biopsycho.2008.10.004
-
Cohen, S., Janicki-Deverts, D., Doyle, W.J., Miller, G. E., Frank, E., Rabin, B. S. and Turner, R. B. (2012) Chronic stress, glucocorticoid receptor resistance, inflammation, and disease risk, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109: 5995–5999. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1118355109
-
Department of Health (2012) Long Term Conditions Compendium of Information, London: Department of Health.
-
Department of Health and Social Care (2019) Advancing Our Health: Prevention in the 2020s, London: Cabinet Office.
-
Epel, E.S., Crosswell, A.D., Mayer, S.E., Mayer, S. A., Prather, A. A., Slavich, G.M., Puterman, E. and Mendesa, W. B. (2018) More than a feeling: a unified view of stress measurement for population science, Frontiers in Neuroendocrinology, 49: 146–169. doi: 10.1016/j.yfrne.2018.03.001
-
Ferry, J-M. (1995) L’Allocation Universelle Pour un Revenu de Citoyenneté, Paris: Éditions du Cerf.
-
Forget, E.L. (2011) The town with no poverty: the health effects of a Canadian guaranteed annual income field experiment, Canadian Public Policy, 37(3): 283–305. doi: 10.3138/cpp.37.3.283
-
Gerber, M., Brand, S., Lindwall, M., Elliot, C. Kalak, N., Herrmann, C., Pühse, U. and Jonsdottir, I. H. (2012) Concerns regarding hair cortisol as a biomarker of chronic stress in exercise and sport science, Journal of Sports Science and Medicine, 11(4): 571–581.
-
Gibson, M., Hearty, W. and Craig, P. (2018) Universal Basic Income: a Scoping Review of Evidence on Impacts and Study Characteristics, Edinburgh: What Works Scotland.
-
Gordon, N.J. (2014) The Conservative case for a guaranteed basic income, The Atlantic, 6 August, www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/08/why-arent-reformicons-pushing-a-guaranteed-basic-income/375600.
-
Government Digital Service (2014) Universal Credit, London: UK Government, https://bit.ly/10PnCw5 (Accessed 8 Jan 2019).
-
Haagh, L. and Rohregger, B. (2019) Universal Basic Income Policies and Their Potential for Addressing Health Inequities: Transformative Approaches to a Healthy, Prosperous Life for All, Copenhagen: WHO.
-
Halliday, J. (2019) Hull asks to be first UK city to trial Universal Basic Income, The Guardian, 19 January, www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2020/jan/19/hull-universal-basic-income-trial (Accessed 27 January 2020).
-
Hassard, J., Teoh, K., Cox, T., Dewe, P., Cosmar, M., Gründler, R., Flemming, D., Cosemans, B. and Van den Broek, K. (2014) Calculating the Cost of Work-Related Stress and Psychosocial Risks: European Risk Observatory Literature Review, Luxembourg: European Agency for Safety and Health at Work.
-
Haushofer, J. and Shapiro, J. (2016) The short-term impact of unconditional cash transfers to the poor: experimental evidence from Kenya, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 131: 1973–2042. doi: 10.1093/qje/qjw025
-
Haushofer, J. and Shapiro, J. (2018) The long-term impact of unconditional cash transfers: experimental evidence from Kenya, https://bit.ly/2zTB4pg.
-
Health and Safety Executive (2016) Work Related Stress, Anxiety and Depression Statistics in Great Britain, 2016, London: Health and Safety Executive.
-
Health and Safety Executive (2018) Work Related Stress, Anxiety and Depression Statistics in Great Britain, 2018, London: Health and Safety Executive.
-
Henderson, B.N. and Baum, A. (2004) Biological mechanisms of health and disease, in S. Sutton, A. Baum and M. Johnston (eds), The Sage Handbook of Health Psychology, London: Sage, pp 69–93.
-
Henley, J. (2018) Finland to end basic income trial after two years, The Guardian, 23 April, www.theguardian.com/world/2018/apr/23/finland-to-end-basic-income-trial-after-two-years (Accessed 27 January 2020).
-
Henley, J. and agencies (2019) Finland’s “free cash” experiment fails to boost employment, The Guardian, 8 February, www.theguardian.com/world/2019/feb/08/finland-free-cash-experiment-fails-to-boost-employment (Accessed 27 Jan 2020).
-
Johnson, E.A., Spring, E. (2018) The Activity Trap: Disabled People’s Fear of Being Active, Manchester: Activity Alliance.
-
Johnson, M.T. and Johnson, E.A. (2019) Stress, domination and basic income: considering a citizens’ entitlement response to a public health crisis, Social Theory & Health, 17(2): 253–271. doi: 10.1057/s41285-018-0076-3
-
Johnson, M.T., Geyer, R., Degerman, D. (2019) Exploring the health case for a trial of Universal Basic Income: evidence from GPs working with the long-term unemployed, Basic Income Studies, 14(2): 1–11, 20190008. DOI: 10.1515/bis-2019-0008. doi: 10.1515/bis-2019-0008
-
Kalia, M. (2002) Assessing the economic impact of stress: the modern day hidden epidemic, Metabolism, 51(6): 49–53. doi: 10.1053/meta.2002.33193
-
Kangas, O., Jauhiainen, S., Simanainen, M., Ylikännö, M. (2019) The Basic Income Experiment 2017–2018 in Finland: Preliminary Results, Helsinki: Ministry of Social Affairs.
-
Kehrer, B.H. and Wolin, C.M. (1979) Impact of income-maintenance on low birth-weight: evidence from the Gary experiment, Journal of Human Resources, 14(4): 434–462. doi: 10.2307/145316
-
Kumari, M., Shipley, M., Stafford, M., Kivimaki, M. (2011) Association of diurnal patterns in salivary cortisol with all-cause and cardiovascular mortality: findings from the Whitehall II Study, Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, 96: 1478–1485. doi: 10.1210/jc.2010-2137
-
Labour Party (2019) It’s Time for Real Change: The Labour Party Manifesto 2019¸ London: The Labour Party.
-
Lombardo, P., Jones, W., Wang, L., et al. (2018) The fundamental association between mental health and life satisfaction: results from successive waves of a Canadian national survey, BMC Public Health, 18(1): https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-018-5235-x. doi: 10.1186/s12889-018-5235-x
-
Marmot, M.G. and Steptoe, A. (2008) Whitehall II and ELSA, in M. Weinstein, J.W. Vaupel and K.W. Wachter (eds) Biosocial Surveys, Washington: National Academies Press, pp 42–59.
-
Office for National Statistics (2019) Healthcare expenditure, UK health accounts: 2017, www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthandsocialcare/healthcaresystem/bulletins/ukhealthaccounts/2017 (Accessed: 28 Jan 2020).
-
Painter, A. (2016) A Universal Basic Income: the answer to poverty, insecurity, and health inequality?, BMJ, 355: i6473.
-
Pettit, P. (2008) A republican right to basic income?, Basic Income Studies, 2(2): https://doi.org/10.2202/1932-0183.1082. doi: 10.2202/1932-0183.1082
-
Pohjanpalo, P. (2019) Free money didn’t help people find jobs, Finland says, Bloomberg.com, 8 February, www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-02-08/finland-finds-basic-income-failed-to-boost-employment (Accessed 27 January 2020).
-
Press Association (2019) Labour would trial Universal Basic Income if elected, John McDonnell says, The Guardian, 12 May, www.theguardian.com/society/2019/may/12/labour-would-trial-universal-basic-income-if-elected-john-mcdonnell-says (Accessed 18 May 2019).
-
Richardson, E., Fenton, L., McCartney, G., Parkinson, J., Pulford, A., Taulbut, M. and Robinson, M. (2018) Income-Based Policies in Scotland: How Would They Affect Health and Health Inequalities?, Edinburgh: NHS Health Scotland.
-
Sheahan, A. (2003) Basic Income Guarantee: Your Right to Economic Security, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
-
Simpson, E.E.A., McConville, C., Rae, G., O’Connor, J.M., Stewart-Knox, B.J., Coudray, C. and Strain, J.J. (2008) Salivary cortisol, stress and mood in healthy older adults: the Zenith study, Biological Psychology, 78(1): 1–9. doi: 10.1016/j.biopsycho.2007.12.001
-
Smith, S.M. and Vale, W.W. (2006) The role of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis in neuroendocrine responses to stress, Dialogues in Clinical Neuroscience, 8(4): 383–395.
-
Standing, G. (2019) Basic Income as Common Dividends: Piloting a Transformative Policy: a Report for the Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer, London: Progressive Economic Forum, www.progressiveeconomyforum.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/PEF_Piloting_Basic_Income_Guy_Standing.pdf.
-
Tang, K.L., Rashid, R., Godley, J. and Ghali, W.A. (2016) Association between subjective social status and cardiovascular disease and cardiovascular risk factors: a systematic review and meta-analysis, BMJ Open, 6: e010137.
-
Valero, J. (2019) Finnish finance minister: ‘case closed’ for Universal Basic Income, www.euractiv.com, 12 February, www.euractiv.com/section/economy-jobs/interview/finnish-finance-minister-case-closed-for-universal-basic-income/ (Accessed 27 Jan 2020).
-
Webber, L., Chalkidou, K., Morrow, Ferguson, B. and McPherson, K. (2018) What are the best societal investments for improving people’s health?, BMJ, 362: k3377.
-
Webber, L., Mytton, O.T., Briggs, A.D., Woodcock, J., Scarborough, P., McPherson, K. and Capewell, S. (2014) The Brighton declaration: the value of non-communicable disease modelling in population health sciences, European Journal of Epidemiology, 29: 867–870. doi: 10.1007/s10654-014-9978-0
| May 2022 onwards | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 72 | 72 | 25 |
| Full Text Views | 21 | 21 | 1 |
| PDF Downloads | 15 | 15 | 1 |
We are a leading social science publisher
committed to making a difference.
Bristol University Press and
Policy Press
bristoluniversitypress.co.uk