Fairness, generosity and conditionality in the welfare system: the case of UK disability benefits
This paper represents a collaboration between a policy researcher and a behavioural scientist who studies cooperation. Our goal was to develop a shared understanding of one particular policy topic, the reforms to the UK system of disability benefits initiated during the last term of the New Labour Government and accelerated under the Conservative-led administrations since 2010. These reforms introduced much stronger focus on conditionality and assessment, aiming to reduce the cost of the benefit by identifying and removing ‘cheaters’ or ‘undeserving’ recipients from the system. The reforms have failed by even their own stated goals. Here, we seek to understand why they seemed appealing and intuitively likely to succeed. We argue that humans are vigilant cooperators, sensitive to cues of need in others, but also highly susceptible to the idea that others are cheating. This vigilance is particularly marked where they lack a reassuring stream of direct personal evidence to the contrary. The vigilance of human cooperative psychology makes ideas of greater conditionality and punishment easy for politicians to conceive of and sell. However, set against this, there are principles that can be used and successfully appealed to in advocating greater generosity in welfare systems. These include the fundamental social similarity of recipients and non-recipients, and the idea that resources are not generated individually but represent the common windfall of a whole group.
-
Aaroe, L. and Petersen, M.B. (2014) Crowding out culture: scandinavians and Americans agree on social welfare in the face of deservingness cues, Journal of Politics, 76(3): 684–97.
-
Activity Alliance and IFF Research (2020) Annual disability and activity survey 2019/20, https://bit.ly/2H4tHf6
-
Alesina, A., Baqir, R. and Easterly, W. (1999) Public goods provision and ethnic divisions, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 114(4): 1243–84.
-
Axelrod, R. and Hamilton, W.D. (1981) The evolution of cooperation, Science, 211(27): 1390–96.
-
Bannerjee, A.V. and Duflo, E. (2019) Good Economics for Hard Times, London: Allen Lane.
-
Barr, B., Taylor-Robinson, D., Stuckler, D., Loopstra, R., Reeves, A. and Whitehead, M. (2016) ‘First, do no harm’: are disability assessments associated with adverse trends in mental health? A longitudinal ecological study, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 70: 339.
-
BBC News (2019) Painkiller campaign leads to benefit claims change, 8 October, www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-bristol-49958847
-
Boyer, P. (2018) Minds Make Societies: How Cognition Explains the World Humans Create, New Haven, NJ: Yale University Press.
-
Boyer, P. and Petersen, M.B. (2018) Folk economic beliefs: an evolutionary cognitive model, Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 41: e158.
-
Briant, E., Watson, N. and Philo, G. (2011) Bad News for Disabled People: How the Newspapers are Reporting Disability. Project Report, Glasgow: Strathclyde Centre for Disability Research and Glasgow Media Unit, University of Glasgow.
-
Burchardt, T. (1999) The Evolution of Disability Benefits in the UK: Re-weighting the Basket, London: Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion, http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/6490/1/The_Evolution_of_Disability_Benefits_in_the_UK_Re-weighting_the_basket.pdf
-
Cameron, D. (2009) David Cameron: we were right to make debt a priority, The Telegraph, 26 March, www.telegraph.co.uk./news/politics/david-cameron/5052949/We-were-right-to-make-debt-a-priority.html
-
Carlsson, F., He, H. and Martinsson, P. (2010) Windfall vs. earned money in the laboratory: do they affect the behavior of men and women differently?, Gothenberg: Working Papers in Economics, 468.
-
ComRes and English Federation of Disability Sport (2016) Media research report, www.activityalliance.org.uk/how-we-help/research/2236-activity-alliance-media-report-august-2016
-
Cosmides, L. (1989) The logic of social exchange: has natural selection shaped how humans reason? Studies with the Wason selection task, Cognition, 31(3): 187–276.
-
Costello, E.J., Compton, S.N., Keeler, G. and Angold, A. (2003) Relationships between poverty and psychopathology: a natural experiment, Journal of the American Medical Association, 290(15): 2023–29.
-
Cowburn, A. and Buchan, L. (2020) Coronavirus: chancellor rejects widespread calls for universal basic income, saying government ‘not in favour’, The Independent, 24 March, www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/coronavirus-universal-basic-income-rishi-sunak-ubi-rebecca-long-bailey-a9421281.html
-
Dalia Research (2017) The EU’s growing support for basic income, https://basicincome.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/DR-2017-survey.pdf
-
Dawes, R.M., McTavish, J. and Shaklee, H. (1977) Behavior, communication and assumptions about other people’s behavior in a common dilemma situation, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 35(1): 1–11.
-
DBC (2017) Supporting those who need it most? Evaluating personal independence payment, https://disabilitybenefitsconsortium.files.wordpress.com/2017/09/supporting-those-who-need-it-most-full-report.pdf
-
Debove, S., Baumard, N. and Andre, J.-B. (2017) On the evolutionary origins of equity, PLoS ONE, 12: e0173636.
-
Delton, A.W., Petersen, M.B., DeScioli, P. and Robertson, T.E. (2018) Need, compassion, and support for social welfare, Political Psychology, 39(4): 907–24.
-
Department for Education, Government Equalities Office and Office for Disability Issues (2015) 2010 to 2015 government policy: equality, www.gov.uk/government/publications/2010-to-2015-government-policy-equality/2010-to-2015-government-policy-equality#appendix-9-the-social-model-of-disability
-
Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) (2011) Disability living allowance reform: impact assessment, www.parliament.uk/documents/impact-assessments/IA11-040E.pdf
-
Disability Benefits Consortium (DBC) (2013) DBC briefing: the PIP 20 metre rule, www.visionuk.org.uk/download/archive_1/docs/DBC_PIP_20_metre_rule_briefing.doc
-
Dryzek, J.S., Bächtiger, A., Chambers, S., Cohen, J., Druckman, J.N., Felicetti, A., Fishkin, J.S., Farrell, D.M., Fung, A., Gutmann, A., Landemore, H., Mansbridge, J., Marien, S., Neblo, M.A., Niemeyer, S., Setälä, M., Slothuus, R., Suiter, J., Thompson, D., Warren, M.E. (2019) The crisis of democracy and the science of deliberation, Science, 363(6432): 1144–46.
-
DWP (2013) The Government’s response to the consultation on the PIP assessment Moving around activity, www.gov.uk/government/consultations/consultation-on-the-pip-assessment-moving-around-activity
-
DWP (2015) 2010 to 2015 government policy: welfare reform, www.gov.uk/government/publications/2010-to-2015-government-policy-welfare-reform/2010-to-2015-government-policy-welfare-reform
-
DWP (2019a) Fraud and error in the benefit system: financial year 2018 to 2019 estimates – tables: fraud and error in the benefit system, 2018 to 2019 estimates, www.gov.uk/government/statistics/fraud-and-error-in-the-benefit-system-financial-year-2018-to-2019-estimates
-
DWP (2019b) Personal independence payment: official statistics to October 2019, www.gov.uk/government/statistics/personal-independence-payment-april-2013-to-october-2019
-
DWP (2019c) PIP assessment guide: part two – the assessment criteria, www.gov.uk/government/publications/personal-independence-payment-assessment-guide-for-assessment-providers
-
DWP (2020a) DWP benefits statistical summary, February 2020, www.gov.uk/government/publications/dwp-benefits-statistics-february-2020/dwp-benefits-statistical-summary-february-2020
-
DWP (2020b) Family resources survey: financial year 2018/19 – disability data tables, www.gov.uk/government/statistics/family-resources-survey-financial-year-201819
-
DWP (2020c) PIP administrative exercise: progress on cases cleared, at 5 January 2020, www.gov.uk/government/publications/pip-administrative-exercise-progress-on-cases-cleared-at-5-january-2020/pip-administrative-exercise-progress-on-cases-cleared-at-5-january-2020
-
DWP (2020d) Stat-xplore: benefit combinations dataset: august 2019, https://stat-xplore.dwp.gov.uk
-
Fehr, E. and Gachter, S. (2000) Cooperation and punishment in public goods experiments, The American Economic Review, 90(4): 980–94.
-
Government Digital Service (2020) Support for those affected by COVID-19, www.gov.uk/government/publications/support-for-those-affected-by-covid-19/support-for-those-affected-by-covid-19
-
Government Digital Service (no date) Claim child benefit, www.gov.uk/child-benefit/eligibility
-
Habyarimana, J., Humphreys, M., Posner, D.N. and Weinstein, J.M. (2007) Why does ethnic diversity undermine public goods provision?, American Political Science Review, 101(4): 709–25.
-
Handler, J. and Hasenfeld, Y. (1991) The Moral Construction of Poverty: Welfare Reform in America, Newbury Park: Sage.
-
Hardin, G. (1968) The tragedy of the commons, Science, 162(3859): 1243–48.
-
Haselton, M.G. and Nettle, D. (2006) The paranoid optimist: an integrative evolutionary model of cognitive biases, Personality and Social Psychology Review, 10(1): 47–66, doi: 10.1207/s15327957pspr1001_3.
-
Henrich, J., Boyd, R., Bowles, S., Camerer, C., Fehr, E., Gintis, H., McElreath, R., Alvard, M., Barr, A., Ensminger, J., Smith Henrich, N., Hill, K., Gil-White, F., Gurven, M., Marlowe, F.W., Patton, J.Q. and Tracer, D. (2005) ‘Economic man’ in cross-cultural perspective: behavioral experiments in 15 small-scale societies, Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 28(6): 795–815.
-
Henrich, J., Ensminger, J., McElreath, R., Barr, A., Barret, C., Bolyanatz, A., Cardenas, J.C., Gurven, M., Gwako, E., Henrich, N., Lesorogol, C., Marlowe, F., Tracer, D. and Ziker, J. (2010) Markets, religion, community size, and the evolution of fairness and punishment, Science, 327: 1480–84.
-
Institute for Fiscal Studies (2014) The Green Budget 2014, London: Institute for Fiscal Studies, www.ifs.org.uk/green-budget/2014
-
Jaeggi, A.V. and Gurven, M. (2013) Natural cooperators: food sharing in humans and other primates, Evolutionary Anthropology, 22(4): 186–95.
-
Johnson, A. (2009) Letters: why professor David Nutt was shown the door, The Guardian, 2 November, www.theguardian.com/politics/2009/nov/02/drug-policy-alan-johnson-nutt
-
Johnson, E. and Spring, E. (2018) The Activity Trap, Manchester: Activity Alliance, www.activityalliance.org.uk/how-we-help/research/4404-the-activity-trap-benefits-or-being-fit
-
Johnson, M.T., Degerman, D. and Geyer, R. (2019) Exploring the health case for a trial of universal basic income, Basic Income Studies, 14(2): 1–11, doi: 10.1515/bis-2019-0008.
-
Kasza, G.J. (2006) War and welfare policy in Japan, The Journal of Asian Studies, 61(2): 417–35.
-
Keizer, K., Lindenberg, S. and Steg, L. (2008) The spreading of disorder, Science, 322(5908): 1681–85.
-
Keizer, K., Lindenberg, S. and Steg, L. (2013) The importance of demonstratively restoring order, PloS ONE, 8: e65137.
-
Klein, N. and Epley, N. (2016) Maybe holier, but definitely less evil, than you: bounded self-righteousness in social judgment, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 110(5): 660–74.
-
Mercier, H. and Sperber, D. (2017) The Enigma of Reason, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
-
Morris, J. (2011) Rethinking Disability Policy, York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation, www.jrf.org.uk/sites/default/files/jrf/migrated/files/disability-policy-equality-summary.pdf
-
Morris, N. (2013) It’s a stunt! Iain Duncan Smith dismisses demands to live on £53 a week, The Independent, 3 April, www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/its-a-stunt-iain-duncan-smith-dismisses-demands-to-live-on-53-a-week-8556985.html
-
Nettle, D. and Saxe, R. (2020) Preferences for redistribution are sensitive to perceived luck, social homogeneity, war and scarcity, Cognition, 198: 104234.
-
Nettle, D., Johnson, E., Johnson, M. and Saxe, R. (2020) Why has the COVID-19 pandemic increased support for universal basic income?, PsyArXiv, doi: 10.31234/osf.io/csr3u.
-
Nettle, D., Panchanathan, K., Rai, T.S. and Fiske, A.P. (2011) The evolution of giving, sharing, and lotteries, Current Anthropology, 52(5): 747–56.
-
Newton, S. and DWP (2018) Government to end unnecessary PIP reviews for people with most severe health conditions, www.gov.uk/government/news/government-to-end-unnecessary-pip-reviews-for-people-with-most-severe-health-conditions
-
Obinger, H. and Schmitt, C. (2019) World war and welfare legislation in Western Countries, Journal of European Social Policy, doi: 10.1177/0958928719892852.
-
Office for Budget Responsibility (2019) Welfare trends report, https://obr.uk/wtr/welfare-trends-report-january-2019
-
Paluck, E.L., Green, S.A. and Green, D.P. (2019) The contact hypothesis re-evaluated, Behavioural Public Policy, 3(2): 129–58.
-
Petersen, M.B., Sznycer, D., Cosmides, L. and Tooby, J. (2012) Who deserves help? Evolutionary psychology, social emotions, and public opinion about welfare, Political Psychology, 33(3): 395–418.
-
Pettigrew, T.F. and Tropp, R.L. (2006) A meta-analytic test of intergroup contact theory, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 90(5): 751–83.
-
Piff, P.K., Wiwad, D., Robinson, A.R., Aknin, L.B., Mercier, B., Shariff, A. (2020) Shifting attributions for poverty motivates opposition to inequality and enhances egalitarianism, Nature Human Behaviour, 4: 496–505, doi: 10.1038/s41562-020-0835-8.
-
Roberts, G. (2005) Cooperation through interdependence, Animal Behaviour, 70(4): 901–8.
-
Sally, D. (1995) Conversation and cooperation in social dilemmas: a meta-analysis of experiments from 1958 to 1992, Rationality and Society, 7(1): 58–92.
-
Smith, B., Kirby, N., Skinner, B., Wightman, L., Lucas, R. and Foster, C. (2018) Physical Activity for General Health Benefits in Disabled Adults: Summary of a Rapid Evidence Review for the UK Chief Medical Officers’ Update of the Physical Activity Guidelines, London: Public Health England, www.gov.uk/government/publications/everybody-active-every-day-a-framework-to-embed-physical-activity-into-daily-life
-
Sperber, D. (1996) Explaining Culture: A Naturalistic Approach, Oxford: Blackwell.
-
Standing, G. (2017) Basic Income: And How We Can Make It Happen, London: Pelican.
-
Stone, D. (1984) The Disabled State, Philadelphia, PN: Temple University Press.
-
Sznycer, D., Delton, A.W., Robertson, T.E., Cosmides, L. and Tooby, J. (2018) The ecological rationality of helping others: potential helpers integrate cues of recipients’ need and willingness to sacrifice, Evolution and Human Behavior, 40(1): 34–45, doi: 10.1016/j.evolhumbehav.2018.07.005.
-
Travis, A. (2009) Chief drug adviser David Nutt sacked over cannabis stance, The Guardian, 30 October, www.theguardian.com/politics/2009/oct/30/david-nutt-drugs-adviser-sacked
-
Trivers, R.L. (1971) The evolution of reciprocal altruism, The Quarterly Review of Biology, 46(1): 35–57.
-
Van Oorschot, W. (2006) Making the difference in social Europe: deservingness perceptions among citizens of European welfare states, Journal of European Social Policy, 16(1): 23–42.
-
Walters, S. (2013) I will go after bogus disabled... some of them DO get better! Ex-TV host who is our new work minister on the UK’s THREE MILLION claiming disability benefit, The Mail on Sunday, 30 March, www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2301735/I-bogus-disabled--DO-better-Ex-TV-host-new-Work-Minister-UKs-THREE-MILLION-claiming-disability-benefit.html
-
Watt, N. (2013a) David Cameron makes leaner state a permanent goal, The Guardian, 12 November, www.theguardian.com/politics/2013/nov/11/david-cameron-policy-shift-leaner-efficient-state
-
Watt, N. (2013b) David Cameron: UK must go further and faster on reducing deficit, The Guardian, 27 February, www.theguardian.com/politics/2013/feb/27/david-cameron-uk-reducing-deficit
-
West, S.A., Griffin, A.S. and Gardner, A. (2007) Social semantics: altruism, cooperation, mutualism, strong reciprocity and group selection, Journal of Evolutionary Biology, 20(2): 415–32.
-
Winnett, R. (2012) 500,000 to lose disability benefit, The Telegraph, 13 May, www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/9263453/500000-to-lose-disability-benefit.html
| May 2022 onwards | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 49 | 49 | 49 |
| Full Text Views | 11 | 11 | 4 |
| PDF Downloads | 8 | 8 | 0 |
We are a leading social science publisher
committed to making a difference.
Bristol University Press and
Policy Press
bristoluniversitypress.co.uk