Narrating the coronavirus crisis: state talk and state silence in the UK
This article is concerned with critically analysing the state’s role in socially constructing the dominant narrative around COVID-19. It focuses on how the state’s ‘truth’ about the virus in general, and deaths in particular, has been generated through a number of social practices which facilitate the dissemination of this ‘truth’ while silencing alternative, more critical, narratives concerning the management of the virus. The paper also considers the question of responsibility. By 2021, the UK’s death rate was the third highest in the world. Given the state’s relentless attempt to shift responsibility onto those breaking the lockdown rules and away from the often-lamentable decisions made by government Ministers and their advisors, who should be held to account for these preventable deaths was, and remains, a key question. This issue is addressed in the last part of the paper.
-
Abbasi, K. (2021) Covid-19: social murder, they wrote – elected, unaccountable, and unrepentant, British Medical Journal, 372: n314, doi: 10.1136/bmj.n314.
-
Ashton, J. with Morris, M. (2020) Blinded by Corona: How the Pandemic Ruined Britain’s Health and Wealth, and What to do About it, London: Gibson Square.
-
Barr, C. and Inman, P. (2020) Low-paid workers more likely to die from Covid-19 than higher earners, Guardian, 11 May.
-
Barrington, R. (2020) Britain’s PPE procurement: chumocracy, cronyism, corruption, UK in a changing Europe, https://ukandeu.ac.uk/britains-ppe-procurement-chumocracy-cronyism-corruption/.
-
BBC News Online (2020a) WHO head: our key message is: test, test, test, 16 March.
-
BBC News Online (2020b) Covid-19: mass testing in Liverpool sees ‘remarkable decline’ in cases, 23 November.
-
BBC News Online (2020c) Liverpool: how one city took on the Covid-19 crisis, 29 November.
-
BBC News Online (2020d) Covid-19: NHS long waits 100 times higher than before, 10 December.
-
BBC News Online (2021) Captain Sir Tom Moore: ‘national inspiration’ dies with Covid-19, 2 February.
-
BBC Scotland (2020) Coronavirus: FAI call into deaths of NHS and care workers, 23 April, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-52395279.
-
Booth, R. (2020) BAME groups hit harder by Covid-19 than white people, UK study suggests, Guardian, 7 April.
-
Booth, R. and Barr, C. (2020) Black people four times more likely to die from Covid-19, ONS finds, Guardian, 7 May.
-
Boseley, S. (2021) 20.5m years of life may have been lost to Covid-19 across 81 countries, study finds, Guardian, 18 February.
-
Bower, T. (2020) Boris Johnson: The Gambler, London: W.H. Allen.
-
Briggs, A., Jenkins, D. and Fraser, C. (2020) NHS test and trace: the journey so far, Health Foundation, 23 September, https://www.health.org.uk/publications/long-reads/nhs-test-and-trace-the-journey-so-far.
-
Bundock, L. (2020) Coronavirus-related deaths of 91 NHS workers could be investigated, Sky News, 5 June, https://news.sky.com/story/coronavirus-related-deaths-of-91-nhs-workers-could-be-investigated-12000937.
-
Butler, P. (2020) Almost 700,000 driven into poverty by Covid-19 crisis in UK, study finds, Guardian, 30 November.
-
Calvert, J. and Arbuthnott, G. (2021) Failures of State: The Inside Story of Britain’s Battle with Coronavirus, London: Mudlark.
-
Campbell, D. (2020) UK ministers face legal challenge for refusal to order PPE inquiry, Guardian, 8 June.
-
Carding, N. (2020) Government counts mailouts to hit 100,000 testing target, Health Service Journal, 1 May, https://www.hsj.co.uk/quality-and-performance/government-counts-mailouts-to-hit-100000-testing-target/7027544.article.
-
Carding, N. (2021) Revealed: nightingale hospitals to cost half a billion pounds in total, Health Service Journal, 20 January, https://www.hsj.co.uk/finance-and-efficiency/revealed-nightingale-hospitals-to-cost-half-a-billion-pounds-in-total/7029345.article.
-
Caul, S. (2021) Counting Deaths Involving National Statistics, London: Office for National Statistics.
-
Chakrabortty, A. (2020) England’s test and trace is a fiasco because this government hates the public sector, Guardian, 17 September.
-
Channel 4 News (2021a) 25 January.
-
Channel 4 News (2021b) 10 March.
-
Clarke, R. (2021) Breathtaking: Inside the NHS in a Time of Pandemic, London: Little Brown.
-
Coleman, R. and Mullin-McCandlish, B. (2021) The harms of state, Free-market common sense and COVID-19, State Crime Journal, 10(1): 170–88. doi: 10.13169/statecrime.10.1.0170
-
Coleman, R., Sim, J., Tombs, S. and Whyte, D. (2009) Introduction: state power crime, in R. Coleman, J. Sim, S. Tombs and D. Whyte (eds) State Power Crime, London: Sage, pp 1–19.
-
Conn, D. (2020) Bereaved relatives call for immediate inquiry into Covid-19 crisis, Guardian, 12 June.
-
Conn, D. (2021) Coroner’s Covid-19 findings stoke calls for inquiry into pandemic policy, Guardian, 18 January.
-
Corrigan, P. and Sayer, D. (1985) The Great Arch: English State Formation as Cultural Revolution, Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
-
Davies, W. (2020) This is no Normal: The Collapse of Liberal Britain, London: Verso.
-
Deeks, J., Raffle, A. and Gill, M. (2021) Covid-19: Government must urgently rethink lateral flow test rollout, Thebmjopinion, 12 January, https://blogs.bmj.com/bmj/2021/01/12/covid-19-government-must-urgently-rethink-lateral-flow-test-roll-out/.
-
Department of Health and Social Care (2020) Major milestone hit as 2 billion items of PPE delivered, 25 June, https://www.gov.uk/government/news/major-milestone-hit-as-2-billion-items-of-ppe-delivered.
-
Dodd, V. and Campbell, D. (2020) UK health watchdog may investigate coronavirus deaths, Guardian, 8 May.
-
Drury, C. (2020) Coronavirus: Liverpool mass testing may be ‘missed opportunity’ as thousands in poorer areas decline to take part, Independent, 25 November.
-
Duncan, P. and McIntyre, N. (2020) Why No 10’s Covid-19 death toll slides don’t tell the whole story, Guardian, 5 May.
-
Eaton, G. (2020) The UK suffers the worst recession of any G7 country, Economist, 12 August.
-
Furlong, A. and Cooper, C. (2020) Britain’s new health boss Dido Harding sparks cries of cronyism, Politico, 22 August, https://www.politico.eu/article/the-businesswoman-leading-britains-mid-pandemic-shakeup-of-public-health/.
-
Gill, M. and Gray, M. (2020) Mass testing for Covid-19 in the UK, British Medical Journal, 371: m4436.
-
Guy, E. (2020) The Johnson government’s vaccine triumphalism masks the true coronavirus death rate in the UK, Canary, 5 December.
-
Hall, D., Lister, J., Hobbs, C., Robinson, P. and Jarvis, C. with Mercer, S. (2020) Privatised and Unprepared: The NHS Supply Chain, Working paper, London: University of Greenwich.
-
Hall, S. (2011) The neoliberal revolution, Soundings, 48: 9–27. doi: 10.3898/ 136266211797146828
-
Hall, S., Critcher, C., Jefferson, T., Clarke, J. and Robers, B. (2013) Policing the Crisis: Mugging, the State and Law and Order, 2nd edn, Basingstoke: Palgrave/Macmillan.
-
Halliday, J. (2020) Gavin Williamson: UK is ‘a much better country than every single one of them’, Guardian, 3 December.
-
Halliday, J. and Boseley, S. (2020) Operation Moonshot: rapid Covid-19 test missed over 50% of cases in pilot, Guardian, 5 November.
-
Hancock, S. (2020) Nightingale hospitals ‘not being used’ amid surging Covid-19 cases and NHS staff shortages, Independent, 29 December.
-
Harris, J. (2021) The British public are careful and calm – the problem is that the government isn’t, Guardian, 17 January.
-
Horton, R. (2020) The Covid-19 Catastrophe: What’s Gone Wrong and How to Stop it Happening Again, Cambridge: Polity Press.
-
indie-SAGE (2021) What is independent Sage?, https://www.independentsage.org.
-
Knapton, S. (2020) Mass coronavirus testing in Liverpool has missed half of positive cases, Government figures show, Telegraph, 3 December.
-
Lawrence, F., Garside, J., Pegg, D., Conn, D., Carrell, S. and Davies, H. (2020) How a decade of privatisation and cuts exposed England to coronavirus, Guardian, 31 May.
-
Mahase, E. (2020) Operation moonshot: what do the leaked documents say?, British Medical Journal, 370: m3558.
-
Malik, K. (2021) Lives are falling apart. Enough talk about inequality, it’s now time to act, Observer, 10 January.
-
Marmot, M. (2020) Why did England have Europe’s worst Covid-19 figures? The answer starts with austerity, Guardian, 10 August.
-
Marsh, S. (2021) Hancock says ‘it’s on all of us’ to help ease Covid-19 lockdown in England, Guardian, 23 February.
-
Mathiesen, T. (2004) Silently Silenced: Essays on the Creation of Acquiescence in Modern Society, Winchester: Waterside Press.
-
Miller, G. (2020) Under Boris Johnson, corruption is taking hold in Britain, Guardian, 9 December.
-
National Audit Office (2020) The Government’s Approach to Test and Trace in England: Interim Report, London: National Audit Office.
-
Oborne, P. (2021) The Assault on Truth: Boris Johnson, Donald Trump and the Emergence of a New Barbarism, London: Simon and Shuster.
-
Observer (2021) Editorial, 24 January.
-
O’Toole, F. (2020) V-Day, really? The vaccine should be a source of global joy, not petty patriotism, Guardian, 9 December.
-
Packham, A. and Rawlinson, K. (2021) ‘Safety is very lax’: staff tell of being forced into the office during lockdown, Guardian, 11 February.
-
Peraudin, F. (2020) Bereaved families call for urgent inquiry into UK Covid-19 response, Guardian, 21 May.
-
Press Association (2020) ‘Chaos and panic’: Lancet editor says NHS was left unprepared for Covid-19, Guardian, 28 March.
-
Prime Minister’s Office (nd) Slides, datasets and transcripts to accompany coronavirus press conferences, https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/slides-and-datasets-to-accompany-coronavirus-press-conferences.
-
Private Eye (2021a) 8–21 January.
-
Private Eye (2021b) 5–18 March.
-
Proctor, K. (2020) Lack of testing and PPE among key England Covid-19 mistakes, MPs told, Guardian, 24 July.
-
Public Health England (nd) Coronavirus (COVID-19) in the UK: deaths.
-
Rose, D. (2020) The £6.75 billion PPE debacle: dossier reveals ministers UNDERBOUGHT then threw fortunes at protective clothing: much of which was overpriced or can never be used, Mail Online, 31 October, https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8898907/Dossier-reveals-ministers-UNDERBOUGHT-threw-6-75billion-protective-clothing.html.
-
Scally, G., Jacobson, B. and Abbasi, K. (2020) The UK’s public health response to covid-19, British Medical Journal, 369: m1932, doi: 10.1136/bmj.m1932.
-
Shaw, N. (2021) Covid could become a ‘disease of the deprived’ in the UK, WalesOnline, 23 February, https://www.walesonline.co.uk/news/uk-news/covid-could-become-disease-deprived-19893693
-
Sim, J. and Tombs, S. (2020) Moving on: burying the coronavirus dead, https://ccseljmuwordpress.com/2020/02/moving-on-burying-coronavirus-deaths.
-
Statista (2021) Incidence of Coronavirus (COVID-19) deaths in the European Economic Area and the United Kingdom as of January 31, 2021, by Country, https://www.statista.com/statistics/1111779/coronavirus-death-rate-europe-by-country/.
-
Stewart, H. and Sample, I. (2020) Coronavirus: enforcing UK lockdown one week earlier ‘could have saved 20,000 lives’, Guardian, 11 June.
-
Strauss, D. and Parker, G. (2020) Longer lockdown drove UK to one of deepest recessions in Europe, Financial Times, 12 August.
-
Syal, R. (2020) England’s test and trace repeatedly failed to hit goals despite £22bn cost, Guardian, 11 December.
-
Syal, R. (2021) No evidence £22bn test-and-trace scheme cut Covid-19 rates in England, say MPs, Guardian, 10 March.
-
Thompson, E.P. (1980) Writing by Candlelight, London: Merlin Press.
-
Thorp, L. (2021) Covid fight ‘undermined’ as 80% in Liverpool fail to get isolation support, https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/newsliverpool/covid-fight-undermined-as-80percent-in-liverpool-fail-to-get-isolation-support/ar-BB1d1685.
-
UK Parliament (2021) Joint Committee on Human Rights: Every Fixed Penalty Notice Issued Under Coronavirus Regulations Must be Reviewed, London: UK Parliament.
-
Whyte, D. (2020) By bailing out vulture capitalists, Rishi Sunak has revealed his true priorities, Open Democracy, 29 September.
-
Wright, O. (2021) Coronavirus: How the UK dealt with its first Covid-19 case, BBC News Online, 31 January.
| May 2022 onwards | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Full Text Views | 167 | 167 | 85 |
| PDF Downloads | 163 | 163 | 95 |
We are a leading social science publisher
committed to making a difference.
Bristol University Press and
Policy Press
bristoluniversitypress.co.uk