‘Ain’t I a human being?’: self-documentation of living in poverty in the face of the abandoning state
How is life in social isolation seen from the viewpoint of people who experience persistent poverty? Given the systemic denial of self-representational agency from those living in poverty and the neoliberalisation of the welfare state, this article turns to those who remained invisible to either the media or the state during the pandemic. In line with current tendencies to prioritise the voice and lived knowledge of people in poverty, we provided our interlocutors with a specifically designed diary tool to allow them to share their mundane experiences and thoughts at their own discretion. Using these diaries of women and men in poverty, and complementary interviews, this article unpacks the ways our participants deal with and understand their everyday relationships with the absent state, mostly welfare and education. Based on the themes that emerged from our interlocutors’ journals, our findings reveal the Janus-faced abandoning/monitoring state that they routinely confront. We then demonstrate how they are constantly chasing the state, struggling to receive the support they lawfully deserve. At the same time, being subjected to practices of state monitoring and surveillance often results not only in mistrust but also in withdrawing almost altogether from the welfare services and social workers, and turning to alternative support networks. We conclude by offering two insights that accentuate, on the one hand, what we and our diarists already know, namely that they count for nothing. Still, on the other hand, the act of self-documentation itself reveals the representational agency of those brave diarists who refuse to forsake their worthiness as citizens.
-
Alston, M. and Chow, A.Y.M. (2021) Introduction - when social work meets disaster: challenges and opportunities, The British Journal of Social Work, 51(5): 1525–30, doi: 10.1093/bjsw/bcab154.
-
Appadurai, A. (2020) Coronavirus won’t kill globalization. But it will look different after the pandemic, Time, [online] https://time.com/5838751/globalization-coronavirus/.
-
Auyero, J. (2012) Patients of the state, Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
-
Ben-Ezra, M. and Hamama-Raz, Y. (2021) Social workers during COVID-19: do coping strategies differentially mediate the relationship between job demand and psychological distress?, The British Journal of Social Work, 51(5): 1551–67. doi: 10.1093/bjsw/bcaa210
-
Benjamin, O. (2020) Mothers’ negotiation of welfare support: the emergence of privatized entitlement, International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 40(11/12): 1439–54. doi: 10.1108/IJSSP-03-2020-0071
-
Beresford, P., Farr, M., Hickey, G., Kaur, M., Ocloo, J., Tembo, D. and Williams, O. (eds) (2021) COVID-19 and Co-Production in Health and Social Care Research, Policy, and Practice – Volume 1: The Challenges and Necessity of Co-Production, Bristol: Policy Press.
-
Brown, W. (2015) Undoing the Demos: Neoliberalism’s Stealth Revolution, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
-
Carmon, T. (2020) Violence against women: the victims seek assistance, rape files are closed, Davar, [online] https://www.davar1.co.il/263277/. (Hebrew)
-
Cooper, M. (2020) Neoliberalism’s family values: welfare, human capital, and kinship, in D. Plehwe, Q. Slobodian and P. Mirowski (eds) Nine Lives of Neoliberalism, London: Verso Books, pp 95–11.
-
Crean, M. (2018) Affective formations of class consciousness: care consciousness, The Sociological Review, 66(6): 1177–93, doi: 10.1177/0038026117751341.
-
Daly, M. (2018) Towards a theorization of the relationship between poverty and family, Social Policy & Administration, 52(3): 565–77, doi: 10.1111/spol.12350.
-
Daly, M. and Kelly, G. (2015) Families and Poverty: Everyday Life on a Low Income. Bristol: Policy Press.
-
Doron, A. (2003) The Israeli welfare regime: changing trends and their societal effects, Israeli Sociology, 5(2): 417–434. (Hebrew)
-
Endeweld, Heller, M.O. and Caradi, L. (2020) The impact of recession and the government’s policy following the Covid-19 crisis on the level of living, poverty and inequality, Social Security, 110: 1–22.
-
Esping-Andersen, G. (1990) The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
-
Gal, J., Krumer-Nevo, M., Madhala, S. and Yanay, G. (2019) Material Assistance to People Living in Poverty: A Historical Survey and Current Trends, Jerusalem: Taub Center, http://taubcenter.org.il/material-assistance-to-people-living-in-poverty/. (Hebrew)
-
Hall, J., Gaved, M. and Sargent, J. (2021) Participatory research approaches in times of Covid-19: a narrative literature review, International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 20: 1–15, doi: 10.1177/16094069211010087.
-
Hall, S.M. (2019) Everyday Life in Austerity: Family, Friends and Intimate Relations, Cham: Springer International Publishing.
-
Hasson, Y., Ben Eliyahu, H. and Tzameret, H. (2021) Hidden Figures: How the Coronavirus Has Affected Women and Men in Israel, Tel Aviv: Adva Center.
-
Herron, R., Dansereau, L., Wrathall, M., Funk, L. and Spencer, D. (2019) Using a flexible diary method rigorously and sensitively with family careers, Qualitative Health Research, 29(7): 1004–15, doi: 10.1177/1049732318816081.
-
Hertzog, E. (2014) Minors’ welfare and bureaucratic violence in Israel, Anthropology of the Middle East, 9(1): 42–58. doi: 10.3167/ame.2014.090104
-
Kaplan, D., Levy, G., Buzhish-Sasson, H., Biton, A. and Kohan-Benlulu, R. (2022) Doing family while poor: agentic hopelessness as lived knowledge, Families, Relationships and Societies, 1–19 (online first). doi: 10.1332/204674321X16474246365913
-
Karadzhov, D. (2020) Expanding the methodological repertoire of participatory research into homelessness: the utility of the mobile phone diary, Qualitative Social Work, 20(3): 813–31, doi: 10.1177/1473325020913904.
-
Krumer-Nevo, M. (2020) Radical Hope: Poverty-aware Practice for Social Work, Bristol: Policy Press.
-
Krumer-Nevo, M. and Benjamin, O. (2010) Critical poverty knowledge: contesting othering and social distancing, Current Sociology, 58(5): 693–714. doi: 10.1177/0011392110372729
-
Krumer-Nevo, M. and Refaeli, T. (2021) COVID-19: A poverty-aware perspective, American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 91(3): 423, doi: 10.1037/ort0000566.
-
Lavee, E. (2021) Low-income breadwinning Israeli mothers negotiating economic survival: the exchange of sex for material resources, in Women, Vulnerabilities and Welfare Service Systems, London: Routledge, pp 125–38.
-
Lavee, E. and Benjamin, O. (2015) Working-class mothers’ school involvement: a class-specific maternal ideal?, The Sociological Review, 63(3): 608–25. doi: 10.1111/1467-954X.12253
-
Lawinski, T. (2010) Living on the Edge in Suburbia: From Welfare to Workfare, Nashville, TN: Vanderbilt University Press.
-
Levy, G. and Kohan-Benlulu, R. (2019) Being civil is not enough: On practices of citizenship of women living in poverty in Israel, Radical Housing Journal, 1(2): 119–35, doi: 10.54825/SOEN8457.
-
Lister, R. (2021) Poverty, 2nd edn, Cambridge: Polity Press.
-
McKenzie, L. (2022) Introduction, in Working Class Collective (ed) Lockdown Diaries of the Working Class, London: The Working Class Collective, pp 31–39.
-
Mei-Ami, N. (2008) Child Allowance in Israel: A Historical Overview, Jerusalem: The Knesset Research and Information Center. (Hebrew)
-
NII (National Insurance Institute) (2018) Poverty and Social Gaps, Jerusalem: NII. (Hebrew)
-
Nouman, H. (2021) Social work practice with ethnic minorities during the COVID-19 pandemic: learning from the Arab minority in Israel, The British Journal of Social Work, 51(5): 1680–99.
-
Patrick, R. (2020) Unsettling the Anti-welfare commonsense: the potential in participatory research with people living in poverty, Journal of Social Policy, 49(2): 251–70, doi: 10.1017/S0047279419000199.
-
Peleg, B. (2021) The social services ministry: 733 new homeless sought help during 2020 at the wake of Covid-19, Ha’aretz, [online] 733 new homeless during Covid-19. (Hebrew)
-
Roll, S., Chun, Y., Kondratjeva, O., Despard, M., Schwartz-Tayri, T.M. and Grinstein-Weiss, M. (2022) Household spending patterns and hardships during COVID-19: a comparative study of the US and Israel, Journal of Family and Economic Issues, 1–21, doi: 10.1007/s10834-021-09814-z.
-
Rosenhek, Z. (1999) The exclusionary logic of the welfare state: palestinian citizens in the Israeli Welfare State, International Sociology, 14(2): 195–215.
-
Salamon, G. (2010) Here are the dogs: poverty in theory, Differences, 21(1): 169–77, doi: 10.1215/10407391-2009-025.
-
Schweiger, G. and Graf, G. (2014) The subjective experience of poverty, SATS, 15(2): 148–67, doi: 10.1515/sats-1001-2014.
-
Simpson Reeves, L., Parsell, C. and Liu, S. (2020) Towards a phenomenology of poverty: defining poverty through the lived experiences of the ‘poor’, Journal of Sociology, 56(3): 439–54, doi: 10.1177/1440783319851204.
-
State of Israel (2021) The Local Authorities During the Coronavirus Crisis, Jerusalem: The State Comptroller. (Hebrew)
-
Stier, H. (2011) Working and Poor, Taub Center Policy Paper No. 2011.06, Jerusalem: Taub Center, pp 153–203.
-
Streeck, W. (2017) Buying Time: The Delayed Crisis of Democratic Capitalism, London: Verso.
-
Strier, R. and Shdaimah, C. (2020) The faintest stirring of hope became possible: pandemic postscript, Ethics and Social Welfare, 14(3): 242–47.
-
Strier, R., Nouman, H. and Kantarovich, N. (2022) Knowing poverty: social workers’ perceptions of poverty knowledge, Journal of Social Work, 22(4): 896–914.
-
Swirski, S. and Dagan-Buzaglo, N. (2014) On the Report of the Committee to Combat Poverty - The Alalouf Committee, Tel Aviv: Adva Center.
-
Swirski, S., Lieberman, A. and Konor-Attias, E. (2019) Near Poverty: Danger of Falling into Poverty, Chances of Joining the Middle Class, Tel Aviv: Adva Center [online] https://adva.org/en/near-poverty/.
-
The Crisis Experts Team (2020) The experts’ report: the implication of the corona virus for education, [online] https://bit.ly/2UyDWmp.
-
Timor-Shlevin, S. (2022) Between othering and recognition: in search of transformative practice at the street level, European Journal of Social Work, 1–13. doi: 10.1080/13691457.2022.2092456
-
Tyler, I. (2013) Revolting Subjects, London and New York: Zed Books.
-
Tzameret-Kretcher, H. (2013) Poverty as Translation: The Professional Discourse on Poverty in Israel, Unpublished PhD dissertation, Tel Aviv: Tel Aviv University [Hebrew].
-
Yona, L. and Nadan, Y. (2021) Mind the gap: parental and professional perceptions of ‘risk’ for children living in poverty, Child & Family Social Work, doi: 10.1111/cfs.12840.
| May 2022 onwards | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Abstract Views | 820 | 820 | 26 |
| Full Text Views | 1001 | 1001 | 38 |
| PDF Downloads | 734 | 734 | 25 |
We are a leading social science publisher
committed to making a difference.
Bristol University Press and
Policy Press
bristoluniversitypress.co.uk