The opposing views in the scholarly debate on evidence-based policy (EBP) have recently been labeled ‘rationalist’ and ‘constructivist’, where the former are positive to EBP and the latter are not. This framing of the debate is suboptimal, as it conflates critical positions that should be kept separate. This article suggests that the debate should be understood as one between idealists, realists, and counter-idealists about EBP. The realist position, that is, that EBP is difficult or impossible to achieve in practice, has already been treated at length in the debate. The conflict between idealism and counter-idealism, to the contrary, has been neglected. This article aims to stimulate the scholarly debate on EBP by initiating a principled discussion between idealism and counter-idealism about EBP, which should motivate proponents of EBP to formulate their ideal with substantial moral arguments. This places the debate on EBP in the context of normative political theory, where it rightfully belongs.
Albæk, E. (1995) Between knowledge and power: utilization of social science in public policy making, Policy Sciences, 28(1): 79–100.
Arvan, M. (2014) First steps toward a nonideal theory of justice, Ethics & Global Politics, 7(3): 95–117.
Bird, S.M., Goldacre, B. and Strang, J. (2011) We should push for evidence based sentencing in criminal justice, BMJ, 342: d612. doi: 10.1136/bmj.d612
Botterill, L.C. (2017) Evidence-based policy, in Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Botterill, L.C. and Hindmoor, A. (2012) Turtles all the way down: bounded rationality in an evidence-based age, Policy Studies, 33(5): 367–79. doi: 10.1080/01442872.2011.626315
Cairney, P. (2016) The Politics of Evidence-Based Policy Making, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Cairney, P. (2017) The politics of evidence-based policymaking, Oxford Research Encyclopedia, doi: 10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.268
Duncan, S. (2005) Towards evidence-inspired policy making, Social Sciences, 61(1): 10–11.
Erman, E. and Möller, N. (2019) A world of possibilities: the place of feasibility in political theory, Res Publica, doi: 10.1007/s11158-018-09415-y
Estlund, D. (2014) Utopophobia, Philosophy and Public Affairs, 42: 113–34. doi: 10.1111/papa.12031
Estlund, D. (2016) Reply to Wiens, European Journal of Political Theory, 15(3): 353–62. doi: 10.1177/1474885115602369
Farrelly, C. (2007) Justice in ideal theory: a refutation, Political Studies, 55(4): 844–64.
French, R.D. (2018) Lessons from the evidence on evidence-based policy, Canadian Public Administration, 61(3): 425–42. doi: 10.1111/capa.12295
Hamlin, A. and Stemplowska, Z. (2012) Theory, ideal theory and the theory of ideals, Political Studies Review, 10: 48–62. doi: 10.1111/j.1478-9302.2011.00244.x
Haynes, L., Service, O., Goldacre, B. and Torgerson, D. (2012) Test, Learn, Adapt: Developing Public Policy with Randomised Controlled Trials, Policy Paper, Cabinet Office, London.
Head, B.W. (2010) Reconsidering evidence-based policy: key issues and challenges, Policy and Society, 29(2): 77–94. doi: 10.1016/j.polsoc.2010.03.001
Jebari, K. (2019) Vad är evidensbaserad policy?, manuscript.
Levy, J.T. (2016) There is no such thing as ideal theory, Social Philosophy and Policy, 33(1–2): 312–33. doi: 10.1017/S026505251600025X
Luton, L.S. (2007) Deconstructing public administration empiricism, Administration & Society, 39(4): 527–44. doi: 10.1177/0095399707303813
Migone, A.R. and Brock, K.L. (2017) Canadian Public Administration, 60(3): 369–96. doi: 10.1111/capa.12224
Mills, C. (2005) ‘Ideal theory’ as ideology, Hypatia, 20(3): 165–84.
Newman, J. (2017) Deconstructing the debate over evidence-based policy, Critical Policy Studies, 11(2): 211–26. doi: 10.1080/19460171.2016.1224724
Nutley, S.M., Walter, I. and Davies, H.T.O. (2007) Using Evidence: How Research Can Inform Public Services, Bristol: Policy Press.
O’Neill, O. (1987) Abstraction, idealization and ideology in ethics, in J.D.G. Evans (ed) Moral Philosophy and Contemporary Problems, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp 55–69.
Östbring, B. (2019) Migrationspolitiska Dilemman: Om Idealism Och Realism I Liberal Politisk Teori, PhD thesis, Lund: Lund University.
Pearce, W., Wessenlink, A. and Colebatch, H. (2014) Evidence and meaning in policy making, Evidence & Policy, 10(2): 161–65.
Sanderson, I. (2009) Intelligent policy making for a complex world: pragmatism, evidence and learning, Political Studies, 57(4): 699–719. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9248.2009.00791.x
Sen, A. (2006) What do we want from a theory of justice?, Journal of Philosophy, 103: 215–38. doi: 10.5840/jphil2006103517
Simmons, J. (2010) Ideal and nonideal theory, Philosophy & Public Affairs, 38: 5–36.
Southwood, N. (2016) Does ‘ought’ imply ‘feasible’?, Philosophy & Public Affairs, 44: 7–45.
Standring, A. (2017) Evidence-based policymaking and the politics of neoliberal reason: a response to Newman, Critical Policy Studies, 11(2): 227–34. doi: 10.1080/19460171.2017.1304226
Stoker, G. and Evans, M. (2016) Evidence-Based Policy Making in the Social Sciences, Bristol: Policy Press.
Strassheim, H. (2017) Bringing the political back in: reconstructing the debate over evidence-based policy: a response to Newman, Critical Policy Studies, 11(2): 235–45. doi: 10.1080/19460171.2017.1323656
Valentini, L. (2012) Ideal vs. non-ideal theory: a conceptual map, Philosophy Compass, 7: 654–64. doi: 10.1111/j.1747-9991.2012.00500.x
Weingart, P. (2003) Paradox of scientific advising, in G. Bechmann and I. Hronszky (eds) Expertise and Its Interfaces: The Tense Relationship of Science and Politics, Berlin: Editions Sigma, pp 53–89.
Wiens, D. (2015) Against ideal guidance, Journal of Politics, 77(2): 433–46. doi: 10.1086/679495
Wiens, D. (2016) Motivational limits on the demands of justice, European Journal of Political Theory, 15(3): 333–52. doi: 10.1177/1474885115578446
Wiens, D. (2018) Rejoinder to Estlund, manuscript.
May 2022 onwards | Past Year | Past 30 Days | |
---|---|---|---|
Abstract Views | 948 | 552 | 58 |
Full Text Views | 733 | 78 | 1 |
PDF Downloads | 301 | 38 | 1 |
Institutional librarians can find more information about free trials here